Friday, November 20, 2026

The OVN License: Towards a Legal Framework for a Regenerative, Peer-to-Peer Economy

Beyond open access: making the commons economically sustainable


For decades, the open-source movement has demonstrated that people can create extraordinary things by collaborating, sharing knowledge and building upon each other's work.

Linux, Wikipedia, collaborative design, open hardware and countless other initiatives have demonstrated the productive power of the commons.

Yet an important problem remains unresolved:

How can we ensure that the economic benefits generated through the use of collectively produced resources contribute to sustaining the people and communities that create them?

Open licenses have made knowledge accessible. Copyleft licenses have helped prevent the enclosure of shared knowledge through proprietary derivatives. The Peer Production License proposed by the P2P Foundation introduces reciprocity based on the nature of the economic organization exploiting the commons.

But peer production networks are evolving. They are developing new ways to organize productive activities, coordinate contributions, distribute benefits and govern shared resources.

Their legal and economic infrastructure needs to evolve accordingly.

This is why we are developing the OVN License.

Our objective is to create a licensing framework that connects the legal conditions for using shared resources with the economic principles and organizational practices of peer-to-peer (P2P) production networks.

We want to make it possible to share openly, collaborate freely, build upon previous contributions and generate economic activity, while establishing meaningful reciprocity between those who use the commons and those who sustain it.

And we want this framework to be useful beyond any single organization or project.

The problem with existing licensing approaches

Copyright is fundamentally a legal mechanism that gives creators control over certain uses of their original works. Licenses use that legal framework to grant permissions to others.

Over time, different licensing approaches have emerged to address different concerns.

Copyright and conventional proprietary licensing

The traditional proprietary model gives rights holders considerable control over how their work can be used, modified and redistributed. Access and commercial exploitation are generally subject to permission and contractual conditions.

This model is compatible with centralized ownership and commercial appropriation, but it does not naturally support open collaboration.

Copyleft: protecting the freedom of the commons

Licenses such as the GNU General Public License (GPL) introduced a powerful alternative.

They allow people to use, modify and redistribute software, including commercially, while requiring derivative distributions to preserve the same freedoms.

Copyleft protects the commons against certain forms of enclosure: someone cannot take GPL-covered software, create a derivative version and distribute it under restrictive proprietary terms.

This is an essential achievement.

However, copyleft does not generally require commercial users to contribute financially or otherwise to the communities maintaining the software. A company can build a profitable business around GPL software without directly supporting its development, provided it respects the license's distribution obligations.

The GPL protects the freedom of the code. It does not necessarily protect the economic sustainability of its contributors.

The Peer Production License: introducing economic reciprocity

The P2P Foundation's Peer Production License (PPL) takes another step.

It distinguishes between different types of economic actors.

Non-commercial use is permitted, while commercial exploitation is restricted to worker-owned businesses and collectives that distribute their financial gains, surplus and benefits among their worker-owners.

Privately owned businesses that generate profits from the labor of salaried employees cannot commercially exploit the work under the PPL.

This is an important contribution to the development of commons-oriented economic models.

It recognizes that not all forms of commercial activity are economically or socially equivalent.

However, it also introduces a relatively specific organizational criterion: worker ownership and distribution of surplus among worker-owners.

What happens when production is organized through a network of independent contributors, cooperatives, nonprofits, small businesses, individual entrepreneurs and other complementary economic actors?

What happens when contributions are distributed across organizational boundaries, and benefits are redistributed according to participation rather than conventional ownership?

What happens when the commons is maintained by a fluid network rather than a single cooperative?

These questions motivated us to explore another approach.

The P2P paradigm requires a different economic logic

The OVN License emerges from a broader distinction between traditional economic paradigms and peer-to-peer production.

Traditional economic models tend to organize production around identifiable firms, ownership structures, employment relationships, contractual exchanges and the accumulation or distribution of profits.

These mechanisms have their place. But they are not the only possible way to organize economic activity.

In a P2P paradigm, production is organized around distributed capabilities, voluntary participation, shared resources, open collaboration and networks of relationships.

Participants can contribute different things, at different times and through different organizational arrangements.

A person can contribute software development, another can provide materials, another can coordinate activities, and another can offer infrastructure, expertise or access to users or markets.

These contributions do not necessarily take place within a single company or employment relationship.

The network becomes the productive structure.

This changes the economic questions we need to ask.

Instead of asking exclusively:

  • Who owns the company?
  • Who employs whom?
  • Who owns the intellectual property?
  • Who receives profits as an owner?

We also need to ask:

  • Who contributes to the productive process?
  • Who maintains and improves shared resources?
  • How are contributions recognized?
  • How are benefits redistributed?
  • How can external economic actors use shared resources without undermining the network that sustains them?
  • How can different organizations cooperate without having to merge into one legal entity?

Contribution becomes an important organizing principle alongside ownership, employment and capital.

This does not mean eliminating markets, businesses or private property. It means creating an economic environment in which these mechanisms can coexist with commons-based production and network-based coordination.

We see this as part of the transition towards a regenerative economy.

A regenerative economy does more than reduce negative externalities. It seeks to replenish the social, ecological and productive conditions on which economic activity depends.

A productive network should be able to reproduce and improve its own capacity to produce: its knowledge, infrastructure, relationships, skills, resources and collective intelligence.

A commons that generates economic benefits but cannot sustain the people and infrastructure maintaining it is not economically regenerative.

What is the OVN License trying to achieve?

The OVN License is intended to establish a legal framework for reciprocal relationships between shared resources, their contributors and the economic networks that sustain them.

Its ambition is to connect three dimensions:

1. The commons

Resources should remain accessible, reusable and improvable. The legal framework should protect their shared character and prevent inappropriate enclosure.

2. Contribution

The people and organizations contributing to the creation, maintenance and improvement of shared resources should be recognized as participants in a productive ecosystem.

3. Reciprocity

Economic actors benefiting from shared resources should participate in sustaining the commons, either through qualifying contributions, agreed economic arrangements or other forms of reciprocity.

The objective is not to impose a universal economic model on every user.

It is to provide a framework within which different P2P networks can establish their own rules for participation, reciprocity and benefit redistribution.

The license should recognize that a network's economic relationships are more complex than a simple relationship between an author and a user.

The main design choices

Developing this framework has required several important conceptual choices.

Choice 1: A generic framework, not a license restricted to Sensorica

The framework originates in the practical experience of Sensorica, an Open Value Network (OVN).

However, we do not want to create a license that only makes sense within Sensorica or depends on its specific organizational structure.

We are therefore developing a generic Commons Framework.

It uses concepts such as:

  • Artifact: a resource covered by the licensing framework, such as software, documentation, designs or other productive outputs.
  • Contributor: an individual or organization contributing to the creation, maintenance or improvement of an artifact.
  • Affiliate: an actor associated with a P2P economic network.
  • Lineage: the traceable history of an artifact and its successive contributions and transformations.
  • Canonical artifact: the recognized reference version of a shared resource.
  • Contribution: an activity or input that helps create, maintain or improve a resource.
  • Reciprocity: the obligations or arrangements through which users contribute to sustaining the commons.
  • P2P economic network: the network within which resources, contributions and economic relationships are organized.
  • External-use agreement: an arrangement governing uses that require additional reciprocity or authorization.
  • Resource-specific module: provisions adapted to the characteristics of a particular category of resource.

This generic foundation allows different P2P networks to adopt the framework and define their own implementation rules.

Nondominium and Sensorica's existing practices are examples of possible implementations, not prerequisites for adoption.

Choice 2: Reciprocity rather than a simple commercial/non-commercial distinction

A major limitation of many licensing approaches is their reliance on a binary distinction between commercial and non-commercial use.

Economic reality is more complex.

A cooperative can conduct commercial activities while contributing to the commons. A small business can generate revenue while participating in a productive network. A nonprofit can generate substantial economic value. An individual can use shared resources commercially without being part of a conventional company.

Conversely, an organization can use resources without directly paying for them while extracting substantial economic benefits from the collective work behind them.

We want the framework to recognize the nature of the relationship with the commons, not simply whether money changes hands.

This is why reciprocity is central to the OVN approach.

The specific reciprocity arrangements can be defined through the applicable network rules and external-use agreements.

Choice 3: Contribution rather than ownership as the basis for participation

Conventional economic arrangements often distribute benefits according to ownership, capital investment or employment status.

OVNs introduce another possibility: recognizing contributions to a productive network and using contribution-based mechanisms to redistribute benefits.

This does not mean that every contribution has to be valued in money, or that every participant receives an identical share.

Different networks can establish their own methods for recognizing contributions and distributing benefits.

The important distinction is that participation in the economic benefits of a commons need not be exclusively determined by ownership of the organization or its intellectual property.

Choice 4: Protecting the commons without preventing economic activity

We do not want to create another framework that makes it difficult to build businesses around open resources.

The objective is not to prevent commercialization.

It is to establish conditions under which economic activity can coexist with the sustainability of the commons.

This means addressing situations where organizations benefit from collectively produced resources without contributing to their maintenance, development or reproduction.

It also means making room for external users who are willing to establish appropriate reciprocal arrangements.

Choice 5: Traceability and lineage

A productive resource does not necessarily have a single creator.

It can evolve through successive contributions from different people and organizations.

The framework therefore needs to recognize the lineage of artifacts, their canonical versions and the contributions made throughout their evolution.

This is important not only for attribution, but also for recognizing the distributed nature of production and establishing legitimate relationships between contributors, resources and networks.

Choice 6: Modular design

Software, hardware, documentation, designs and other resources do not necessarily have identical legal and practical requirements.

Rather than forcing every resource into one rigid set of rules, we are developing a common framework with resource-specific modules.

The first module under development concerns software.

This module addresses the rights and conditions associated with running, using, copying, modifying, integrating, distributing, hosting and forking software, as well as the recognition of lineage, qualifying improvements and reciprocal arrangements.

The intention is to create a coherent framework that can subsequently be extended to other resource categories.

How is this different from the Peer Production License?

We see the P2P Foundation's Peer Production License as an important predecessor and source of inspiration.

Both approaches recognize that the commons should not be treated as an unlimited source of resources for extractive commercial activity.

However, their approaches to reciprocity differ.

The Peer Production License establishes a particular distinction between non-commercial use and commercial use by worker-owned businesses and collectives.

The OVN License explores a broader network-oriented framework.

Rather than making worker ownership the universal criterion for legitimate commercial exploitation, it seeks to establish relationships between the use of resources, contribution, network participation and reciprocal arrangements.

This distinction matters because a P2P network can involve many different economic actors without requiring them to adopt the same legal or ownership structure.

A cooperative, an independent contributor, a nonprofit, a small enterprise and a community organization can all participate in the same productive network.

The question becomes how their relationships with the commons are organized, not whether they all fit into one organizational category.

The OVN License is therefore not intended to replace the Peer Production License. It explores another approach to commons-based reciprocity, designed around distributed economic networks.


6. Sensorica: a practical origin for this work

This work is not emerging from abstract legal speculation.

It is rooted in years of experimentation with Sensorica, an Open Value Network.

Sensorica has explored ways to organize collaborative production without relying exclusively on conventional company structures.

Its practices include:

  • Distributed participation by individuals and organizations.
  • Shared productive resources and infrastructure.
  • Open contribution accounting.
  • Recognition of different forms of contribution.
  • Network-based coordination and governance.
  • Mechanisms for redistributing benefits according to participation.
  • Collaboration between independent economic actors.

One important conceptual distinction in this approach is between ownership and participation rights.

A contributor does not necessarily need to own a portion of an organization or an intellectual property asset to participate in the benefits generated through their contributions.

This opens the possibility of organizing productive relationships around contribution-derived participation rather than conventional equity ownership.

The OVN License seeks to give part of this economic architecture a legal expression.

It is an attempt to connect the commons with the economic practices that sustain it.


7. Nondominium: the technological infrastructure

The development of the OVN License is also connected to Nondominium.

Nondominium is an open-source infrastructure developed within the Sensorica ecosystem, using Holochain and the Valueflows/hREA data model to represent resources, agents, economic events and productive relationships.

It is not a blockchain-based system.

Its agent-centric architecture offers possibilities for representing distributed networks without requiring all participants to depend on a single centralized platform.

This is relevant because a licensing framework based on contribution, resource lineage and network reciprocity needs more than legal text.

It needs ways to represent and validate the relationships described by that framework.

For example:

  • Which resource is covered by the license?
  • What is its canonical version?
  • Who contributed to its creation or improvement?
  • How are successive versions related?
  • Which network recognizes or validates particular contributions?
  • What reciprocal arrangements apply to external users?
  • How are benefits associated with contributions?

Nondominium can provide technological infrastructure for representing these relationships.

The license and the software have different functions.

The license establishes legal permissions and obligations. The infrastructure provides mechanisms to record, coordinate and validate relevant information and activities.

Neither replaces the other.

Together, they can help make a network-based economic model operational.


8. How can people involved in open source benefit?

The OVN License is intended to address several persistent problems in open production.

The sustainability problem

Many open-source projects depend on unpaid labor, grants, donations or the goodwill of a relatively small group of maintainers.

The work can generate substantial economic value elsewhere, while the people maintaining it struggle to sustain their activities.

The framework explores ways to establish reciprocal relationships between users and the commons.

The free-rider and extraction problem

An organization can build a profitable business around collectively produced resources without supporting the people and infrastructure behind them.

The license seeks to provide mechanisms for addressing this asymmetry.

The organizational mismatch problem

Many open licenses assume a relatively straightforward relationship between an author, a work and its users.

But peer production is often distributed across individuals, cooperatives, nonprofits, businesses and informal groups.

The OVN framework is designed to accommodate this diversity.

The contribution-recognition problem

Conventional intellectual property arrangements tend to emphasize authorship and ownership.

They do not necessarily capture the broader network of contributions involved in maintaining and evolving a resource.

The framework introduces contribution and lineage as important dimensions.

The fragmentation problem

Different networks often develop their own rules and mechanisms for sharing resources and distributing benefits.

A common conceptual and legal framework could facilitate interoperability and cooperation between them.

The commercialization dilemma

Open-source contributors should not have to choose between making their work accessible and protecting the economic sustainability of the productive community.

We want to explore a third possibility: open sharing combined with meaningful economic reciprocity.

Not just for Sensorica: an invitation to other P2P networks

Although the framework originates in Sensorica's experience, it is not intended to be exclusive to Sensorica.

We believe it could be useful to:

  • Open-source software communities.
  • Open hardware initiatives.
  • Worker cooperatives and open cooperativism projects.
  • Commons-based peer production networks.
  • Distributed research and innovation networks.
  • Circular economy initiatives.
  • Community-based manufacturing networks.
  • Ecological and regenerative economy initiatives.
  • Federated networks of independent organizations.

Different networks will have different economic models, governance arrangements and contribution-recognition mechanisms.

The framework should allow this diversity rather than impose one organizational template.

The idea is to provide a common legal foundation that networks can adapt through their own social and economic rules.

We are developing this as an open framework, and we welcome critical feedback, experimentation and collaboration.

Towards an economy that can reproduce itself

The deeper motivation behind this work is a transition in how we understand production and economic organization.

The industrial economy has largely organized production around capital accumulation, hierarchical firms, ownership and market transactions.

Open-source and commons-based production have demonstrated that another form of productive organization is possible.

But openness alone is not enough.

A commons needs people who maintain it, infrastructure that supports it, resources that enable it to grow and economic mechanisms that allow its contributors to sustain their activities.

We need to move beyond the idea that sharing and economic sustainability are opposing objectives.

We need mechanisms that allow them to reinforce each other.

The P2P paradigm offers a different way of organizing productive capacity: through distributed networks, shared resources, contribution, collaboration and adaptive governance.

The regenerative economy adds another important dimension: economic activity should reproduce and strengthen the social, ecological and productive conditions on which it depends.

The OVN License is one contribution towards that transition.

It is an attempt to develop legal infrastructure for a world in which the commons can remain open, productive networks can sustain themselves, and economic benefits can circulate in ways that reinforce rather than undermine collective productive capacity.

Our ambition is simple, but consequential:

Make it possible to build an economy around shared resources without making the people who create and sustain those resources economically invisible.

Make reciprocity part of the architecture of the commons.

And make the legal infrastructure of peer production evolve alongside its technological and organizational infrastructure.

The commons should not merely be open. It should be sustainable, productive and regenerative.

Thursday, August 27, 2026

What is collaborative entrepreneurship?

Collaborative entrepreneurship is a form of entrepreneurship proposed and practiced by Sensoricans, inside the Open Value Network (OVN) model, to incubate open ventures. The substance lives in practice: the Venture page, the OVN economic model, Sensorica's native working documents, and the recent effort to treat p2p, commons-based peer production, and collaborative entrepreneurship as complexity-processing practices.

This document is a conceptual presentation, leading to a proposition of an educational program in collaborative entrepreneurship. 

Working definition

Collaborative entrepreneurship is the practice of initiating, attracting, coordinating, and stewarding an open venture: a permissionless, transparent, for-benefit economic operation that clusters peer-produced resources into a living context of work, shares risk among contributors, accounts for heterogeneous contributions, and redistributes benefits without turning contributors into employees or the venture into privately owned equity.

Monday, August 10, 2026

HealthNet: Rebuilding Trust in Open Medical Innovation

The Vision: An Ecosystem for Open Healthcare

Some of the world's most urgent health needs go unmet, not because solutions are impossible, but because they are unprofitable. Rare diseases, affordable therapies, and do-it-yourself (DIY) medical devices rarely attract the investment of large manufacturers. HealthNet is a project designed to change that.

Young cystic fibrosis patient at Sainte Justine Hospital using the PEP Master device.

HealthNet is a new model for creating, verifying, and sharing open source medical devices and software. It brings together developers, researchers, medical professionals, and patients into a single collaborative ecosystem, one where high-quality, life-improving solutions can be built in the open and trusted by everyone who depends on them. Our goal is to prove that healthcare innovation can be transparent, collaborative, and accessible to all, without sacrificing safety or quality.

Tuesday, May 26, 2026

Complexity Driven Development


We are living through a strange historical moment. Everywhere we look, institutions appear increasingly incapable of governing the systems they created. Governments struggle to respond to cascading crises. Corporations drown in their own internal coordination overhead. Supply chains fracture unpredictably. Digital transformation programs stall despite massive investments. Entire industries experience accelerating instability despite unprecedented technological sophistication.

Yet technology itself is not slowing down. AI, automation, distributed systems, digital platforms, global logistics, climate feedback loops, geopolitical interdependence and planetary-scale information networks are dramatically increasing the complexity of civilization itself.

The contradiction is becoming difficult to ignore: our systems are becoming more interconnected, dynamic, and interdependent than ever before, while the organizational models we use to manage them remain fundamentally industrial-age.

This is not merely a management problem. It is a computational problem, and increasingly, it is becoming a civilizational problem. (ref. Sensorica)

Saturday, May 23, 2026

The Grammar That Never Outgrows Itself

On fractal composability, and why the best systems have very small hearts



Consider two systems that seem to have nothing in common. The first is a music composition language written in Rust. You describe a melody the way you might describe a sentence: pitch and duration, sequences of notes, simultaneous voices, modifiers that wrap a phrase and give it context. You write music like you write code, and then you render it to audio. The second is a protocol for governing shared resources across a peer-to-peer network. A makerspace in Montreal has a 3D printer sitting idle. A cooperative across town needs one. The protocol lets them find each other, negotiate terms, transfer custodianship, and record the whole interaction without any platform taking a cut or any central authority imposing the rules. Governance travels with the resource itself.

Different domains. Different problems. And yet, when you look at their internal structure, you find the same pattern at work.

The Distinction That Matters


Most systems are built by accumulation. You start with a core and keep adding parts. You add a module for this, a layer for that, a plugin for the other thing. Over time the system becomes capable, and also becomes impossible to hold in your head. The complexity compounds because each new part adds surface area.

A small class of systems works differently. They are built from a single primitive that can contain itself. You don’t add parts: you compose the primitive with itself, recursively, at any depth. The system grows not by accumulating components but by elaborating its own grammar.

The technical name for this property is fractal composability. A system is fractally composable when its combination operation is closed: any composition of parts produces something that can in turn be composed, without ever leaving the grammar. A modular system has parts you can swap. A fractal system has a primitive whose recursive self-application generates the whole space.

The difference matters because closed systems don’t develop seams. There is no boundary where “inside the grammar” ends and “outside the grammar” begins. You can always go deeper, wrap more context, compose at a higher level, and the system stays coherent throughout.  Read more... 

--------------
Sensorica is implementing its OVN model for material peer production. You can donate to support the amazing people who have sacrificed for the past 15 years to refine peer production.

Wednesday, April 22, 2026

Our feedback on --> Cautious hope: Prospects and perils of communitarian governance in a Web3 environment

The goal of this post is to provide feedback on the Cautious hope: Prospects and perils of communitarian governance in a Web3 environment paper written by Nancy Ettlinger (Professor of Geography at The Ohio State University), in 2024. More importantly, I will nuance some statements about Sensorica and address some factually false ones. 

Before we begin, it is probably important to mention that, to my recollection, the author has never contacted any Sensorica affiliate before publishing this paper. I also don't know what sources of information Nancy used to learn about Sensorica, apart from one paper written by Pazaitis, A. (2020), provided as reference (Breaking the chains of open innovation: Post-blockchain and the case of Sensorica) and a link to a P2PFoundation wiki page on Sensorica. 
I discover the paper in 2026 and I sent my feedback to Nancy, which is the first version of this document. She got back to me the next day with her feedback to my feedback, which I integrated into this final version. 

Friday, March 20, 2026

Nondominium - A Coordination Layer for Parallel Infrastructure

Executive Summary


Critical infrastructure no longer behaves like a set of separate sectors. Energy, communications, finance, transport, manufacturing, supply chains, water, and public governance now operate as a tightly coupled system of systems. Failures in one layer increasingly propagate into the others, turning local disturbances into systemic shocks (Buldyrev et al., 2010; Helbing, 2013; CISA, 2025; DOE, 2023).

This is not a small market problem. Global supply chains alone account for over $10 trillion in annual intermediate goods trade, while infrastructure investment requirements exceed $3.3 trillion annually and rise toward $7 trillion when climate-adjusted needs are included (McKinsey, 2020; Woetzel et al., 2016; OECD, 2017). Yet recent evidence suggests that the binding constraint is often not capital itself, but coordination: the ability to govern interdependent assets, actors, and processes across fragmented institutional boundaries (World Bank, 2020).

Tuesday, November 4, 2025

From Digital Commons to Coordinated Commons: How Web3 Solves Open Source Fragmentation


The open-source movement is founded on the principle of sharing. Developers are granted the freedom to view, use, modify, and distribute code, a pool of shared knowledge known as digital commons. This freedom, however, carries an inherent paradox: the ease of copying code often leads to unwanted proliferation or project fragmentation, draining resources and creating chaos for users.

This post explores the governance, social, and economic failures inherent in traditional open-source development and presents a new paradigm: using Web3 primitives like blockchain, NFTs, and DAOs to enforce coordination, accountability, and sustainable development.

Wednesday, October 15, 2025

Complexity Rising: Are We Living Through the Collapse of Hierarchy?



In our previous post Are We Living Through Collapse? Complexity, Digital Technology, and the Future Beyond Capitalism we proposed complexity as the main cause of the socioeconomic turbulence that we experience today. Here we double down on this proposition by addressing Yaneer Bar-Yam’s paper Complexity Rising.

Collapse rarely looks like fire and ruins. Most often, it feels like drift, a slow unraveling of institutions, the loss of confidence in systems that once seemed unshakable, a spreading sense that no one is in control anymore. The question that haunts our time is not whether society will collapse, but whether it already is.

Over the last few decades, researchers across economics, ecology, and complexity science have been circling around the same idea: our world is entering a transition phase. The mechanisms that once allowed civilization to grow and adapt are breaking down. And yet, from the midst of that breakdown, a new kind of order is trying to emerge.

Tuesday, October 7, 2025

Epistemology of Organizations in an Age of Complexity: Firms, Open Networks, and AI

As the global economy grows more complex, dynamic, and uncertain, the epistemic fitness of organizational forms, how they sense, validate, decide, and learn becomes central to innovation capacity and long-term performance. This essay outlines a research program to develop a comparative framework for the epistemology of organizations. It contrasts centralized firms (pre- and post-digital) with open networks (peer-to-peer) and explores the transformative potential of hybrid AI–P2P epistemic models. Grounded in established literature from Coase and Williamson to Benkler and modern complexity theorists, this work situates its urgency in the context of rising systemic turbulence. The central argument is that in an era defined by uncertainty and complexity, the competitive advantage shifts from efficiencies of scale to efficiencies of learning, anticipation and coherent joint action, making organizational epistemology the critical determinant of future economic dominance.

Monday, September 22, 2025

Beyond Open Access: How Peer-to-Peer Principles are Building the Next Generation of Scientific Tools

 

The term open science is rapidly gaining traction in academic circles. For many, it signifies a move towards greater transparency and accessibility, primarily through open-access publications and the sharing of research data. This is a crucial and welcome development, breaking down paywalls and fostering a more collaborative scientific discourse. But what if this is just the tip of the iceberg? The principles underpinning open science are part of a much deeper societal transformation, one that is not only changing how we share knowledge but how we create, innovate, and produce?

This shift extends far beyond the university walls. We see it in the digital infrastructure that powers our world, with open source software like Linux running the vast majority of web servers. We see it in our quest for knowledge, where collaborative endeavors like Wikipedia have built a comprehensive encyclopedia, contributed to by a global network of volunteers. We see it in media, finance, and manufacturing, where decentralized and collaborative models are challenging traditional, top-down institutions.

Thursday, September 11, 2025

Composting Capitalism: How Peer Production Reduces Waste and Builds a Regenerative Economy


Economies, like ecosystems, live and die. Firms rise, accumulate resources, compete, and eventually collapse. In capitalist economies, when firms “die,” their accumulated knowledge, infrastructure, and social coordination often rot away—liquidated, privatized, or locked behind intellectual property walls. This resembles an ecosystem where fallen trees never decompose, where nutrients are trapped in unusable form, leading to stagnation and scarcity.

But ecosystems thrive precisely because death is followed by composting. Fallen matter is recycled into fertile ground for new growth. In this essay, we argue that commons-based peer production (CBPP)—the collaborative creation of digital and material goods outside market logics—functions more like an ecosystem’s forest floor than capitalism’s landfill. By reducing resource misallocation, improving recycling of knowledge and materials, and minimizing losses from organizational “death,” CBPP offers a regenerative economic logic better suited to a resource-constrained planet.

Wednesday, September 3, 2025

The Missing Bridge: Why Complexity Economics and Peer-to-Peer Must Converge



There is a puzzle at the heart of our economic future. On one side stands the Santa Fe Institute (SFI) and its decades-long work on complexity economics — models of self-organization, emergent order, adaptive systems, and networked coordination. On the other side stand the theorists and practitioners of the peer-to-peer (P2P) economy — commons-based peer production, open source software, blockchain, DAOs, and open value networks.

Both are deeply concerned with the same reality: economies as complex adaptive systems. And yet, strangely, these two intellectual worlds rarely acknowledge one another. Even stranger, some within each camp view the other with skepticism or even disdain.

But this gap is a problem. It must be bridged. Because P2P is no longer a fringe utopia — it is an established, indispensable mode of production. And complexity economics is no longer a fringe critique of neoclassical orthodoxy — it is a robust and maturing science. Together, they could form the intellectual foundation for a new economic paradigm.

Tuesday, September 2, 2025

Are We Living Through Collapse? Complexity, Digital Technology, and the Future Beyond Capitalism




The word “collapse” usually conjures images of sudden catastrophe: cities abandoned, empires falling overnight, institutions crumbling in chaos. But collapse can also look much slower — a gradual unraveling where the signs are everywhere but hard to pin to a single moment. More and more scholars are beginning to argue that this is where we are today: global society is in the midst of collapse.

This doesn’t mean the world will end tomorrow. It means that the institutions and economic logics that sustained industrial modernity — capitalism, liberal democracy, and even state socialism — are increasingly unable to cope with the world they have helped create.

The Case for Collapse

The idea that we are living through collapse is not new, but it has gained momentum. In The Epochal Crisis of Global Capitalism (2024), William Robinson describes a multidimensional breakdown: economic stagnation, political disillusionment, deepening inequality, ecological tipping points, and rising geopolitical conflict. For Robinson, this is not just another downturn — it’s an epochal crisis, one that capitalism cannot resolve within its own logic.

Friday, July 25, 2025

Beyond the Ledger: Why Blockchain and DAOs Fall Short for Complex Economic Organizations, and How OVNs Point the Way Forward

The Global Economic Transition

We are witnessing a profound transformation in the architecture of global economic activity. The traditional capitalist system, rooted in firm hierarchies, proprietary assets, and market-based transactions, is giving way to a networked economy. This emergent configuration is typified by commons-based peer production (CBPP), open source collaboration, distributed knowledge networks, and peer-to-peer (p2p) collaboration. Examples abound: permissionless blockchains, distributed scientific research initiatives, decentralized media platforms, and open educational resources.

In parallel, the digital infrastructures enabling these formations are evolving. Initially celebrated as a breakthrough in decentralized coordination, blockchain technologies and Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs) are revealing inherent limitations when tasked with modeling complex economic processes and sustaining full-fledged economic organizations. In contrast, newer agent-centric approaches, such as the Open Value Network (OVN) model built on Resource-Event-Agent (REA) accounting, the Valueflows vocabulary, hREA logic, and Holochain as a distributed substrate, are showing greater promise.

This blog post draws from the experience of real-world p2p production networks such as Sensorica, and analyzes the foundational limitations of blockchain/DAO-based systems while advocating for a hybrid architecture of economic coordination.

Thursday, May 1, 2025

Integrating Holochain, Mattereum and OVN: A Framework for Peer Production

From Happenings Community: 

Sacha Pignot has kindly shared the latest blog from his own Alternef Digital Garden with us at hAppenings.community this week! Sacha introduces one of his visionary projects: a revolutionary convergence of decentralizing technologies; Holochain, hREA, and Mattereum. He walks us through the key elements of his integration, exploring how these complementary tools empower resilient, sustainable economic models that prioritise cooperation and equitable value distribution. Sacha is a full-stack developer with a deep knowledge of decentralizing tech, peer-to-peer networks and a passion for education and travel. Amongst the projects he’s contributing his talents to is hAppenings.community’s Requests & Offers HC/MVP. We’ll be sharing more about our progress in the coming months.

Read more here... 




Sunday, May 9, 2021

Next generation food machines and how Sensorica approaches food crisis

 This is still a draft (third version). Come back for the final version, you'll probably be surprised.

 --------------------------------

The irony is that when the proverbial S&!# hits the fan, supply chains are disrupted and some people die of starvation, while being surrounded by an abundance of local food sources. Our current economy is very well organized to maximize wealth generation, which means a balance between fulfilling desires and needs of the population, while making money. But at the same time, our economy is unsustainable and fragile. It relies on a web of centralized systems, designed during the industrial era, which are themselves fragile. If one of them fails, the others follow. For example, during the 2008 financial crisis people still needed to eat and farmers still possessed the land and the machines to produce food, but the global food market was greatly disrupted. In capitalism, the market is supposed to readjust to fulfill a new need, but that cannot happen fast enough when the economic infrastructure is affected by a crisis. In socialism, or planned economies, the Government is not well suited to deal with complex situations. Food supply chains can be disrupted because of a regional armed conflict, oil price fluctuations, financial system collapse, bad weather conditions, pandemic, to name just a few, without digressing into nuclear and asteroid collisions. The best way to deal with these situations is a mix of button-up and top-down approaches within a commons-based peer production framework.

Venezuela food crisis, fallout of a mismanaged economy
Store in Venezuela, country with the largest oil reserves.

In normal times, entire populations depended on staples produced by the industrial agriculture. These products are designed to concentrate a lot of nutrients and, in normal times, it makes economic sense to consume them. The paradox is that when access to these products is disrupted, people can starve while being surrounded by an abundance of food. Many indigenous eatable plants grow around us but we have forgotten how to prepare them. I live in Canada and the great majority of food products that are available in groceries are not indigenous. In times of crisis we eat what we find. Are we prepared to process local food sources?

Ciorbă de urzici. Reţetă de post. Este gata imediat şi e foarte gustoasă
Delicious Romanian nettle soup

Modern technology allows us to more efficiently extract and concentrate nutrients from indigenous plants that are not part of our diet in normal times, as they compete with modern agriculture products.

If one day nettles are the only remaining thing that we can eat we'll need time to learn how to prepare them. To get the equivalent in protein of a steak, one needs to eat a 25Kg stack of nettles. Obviously no one can have that in a single serving. In times of crisis, knowing how to make nettle soup is not enough. We need to learn how to extract and concentrate the protein, and how to cook a delicious meal much like a filly tofu dish. That requires learning time and specialized tools. If it is not in our culture to eat nettles, in normal times it is hard to convince people to learn how to prepare them or to invest in equipment to process them.

How to tap into the latent food capacity and be always prepared for rough times? The solution proposed by Greens for Good, an open venture nurtures within the Sensorica OVN, is a versatile food processor that in normal times can mill corn, extract oil from seeds, make tofu, make noodles and all sorts of other tings, while also being able to process eatable indigenous plants. On top of guaranteeing food security, this technology also makes food more sustainable by expanding our food sources, and by encouraging consumption of plant-based proteins instead of animal protein. This seams like a very ambitious plan, but we are not in uncharted territory.

In recent years, 3D printing has revolutionized fabrication. A 3D printer is a versatile technology that can come in the form of a desktop machine able to make toys, and can be easily scaled to a larger rig that can build an entire house in a single day. Almost anything that we can imagine, of any shape and practically of any type of material can be 3D printed. Sensoricans' plan for food processing is similar to what what 3D printing has done to fabrication.

3D printing was invented in the 80'. The Fused Deposit Modeling (FDM) patent expired in 2009, and marked the beginning of the 3D revolution, with the open source hardware community swarming this technology. Sensorica's economic model builds on the open source mode of innovation, inheriting the same properties of rapid development and viral dissemination. But it adds an economic layer on top of the innovation model to ensure proper dissemination, cultural appropriation and adoption of the new technology, this increasing its impact.

The food processing equivalent of the 3D printer is an extruder. The most familiar representation is the meat grinder. The same design pattern is also used to mince meat, extract juice, extract oil, pattern (make pasta), grinde, and more recently to produce textured vegetableprotein for plant-based meat analogous.

The project was proposed by Joshua Pearce from Michigan Tech University. It is now composed of a diverse group of individuals and organizations (such as academic labs, NGOs, food processing equipment manufacturers, food producers and innovation intermediaries), spanning 5 continents. You can join them on Discord.
 
The idea of the extruder came from the work of Bruce Merlo, who made the connection between a green leaves protein extractor and the equipment used in textured vegetable protein (TVP). Unai Gaztelu from SMART Center Tanzania became very instrumental in guiding the development process close to the need of local communities in developing countries. Alexis Alonso helps conceptualizing the project. Sebastian Klemm from Proofing Future is wordsmithing the project and leads our outreach efforts. Make sure you talk to Mayssam Daaboul if you desire to join us and formalize a partnership.  


In the middle of May 2002, the project entered the design phase of the extruder, where open source hardware was remixed with scaled-down industrial solutions to build a device capable of executing two or three labor-intensive and repetitive food processing activities (grinding, oil extraction, etc.), and at the same time be capable of extracting and concentrating proteins from indigenous leafy biomass.  


Sketch of a generic extruder

 

In September 2022 the network focuses on the prototyping and testing of an open source decanter centrifuge, a critical component of the extruder, responsible for separating fluids and solids according to their density differentiation. 


Have an idea about how to improve this post? Please leave comments blow.


Thursday, November 22, 2018

eco2FEST – Week 2: Building Society from the Ground Up


It was an ambitious second week of eco2FEST with workshops and conferences revolving around four different themes: Public Policies, Governance, Habitation, and Urban Agriculture. A lot of important questions were raised as citizens, entrepreneurs, and government officials worked through them all to find collaborative solutions.
Even when no concrete solutions were proposed though, the discussions set the stage for a more focused framing of these themes in the future.

Public Policies

At their most basic, public policies are the intersection between what citizens ask for and what governments can provide. It is this constant flux from one side to the other that creates the common ground of how society is run. Finding a common ground that’s truly for the benefit of the greater good, however, is a different story. This has been the root cause for countless of political struggles since the dawn of civilization.
For any equilibrium to be achieved, there has to be a balance of energy or power on all sides. And that starts with trust and a willingness to collaborate. Governments need to make a greater effort to seek input from citizens impacted by proposed policies while citizens need to take initiative to engage in constructive dialogue with government officials. Only then can innovative public policies take shape.
During the Public Policies segment of eco2FEST, Guillaume Lavoie – professor at ENAP and former city councillor of Montreal – observed that citizens have been asking their elected officials the wrong question about innovation. Instead of just seeking their support for innovation, elected officials should be asked, “What is your level of tolerance for disruption?”
Historically, governments often favour stability while businesses mostly thrive on disruption. But for overall progress to happen in society, it depends on government’s ability to stomach change.
Businesses have always been a step ahead of governments not only because they embrace change, but also because they actively seek out public opinion. If governments want to keep up, they have to do the same and go a step further by establishing units or processes that provide future projections based on current socio-economic trends.
This will allow governments to at least proactively prepare for future growth rather than reacting too late to realities on the ground. It will result in more opportunities for governments to engage in timely discussions with the public.
Besides examining the role of government, eco2FEST participants also considered the other side of the equation: how can we empower citizens with the notion that they have the right to express their opinions on how society is run?
Participatory democracy was brought up several times as a potential way for people to get in the habit of working together with the government. Of course, it means that the government has to transition to that concept and introduce how it works early in the education system.
Once citizens start to participate more and governments have a better pulse on what the needs are, what’s the best way to use crowdsourced data effectively to implement public policies? This was another sticky point in the workshop discussions last week.
For example, there’s a massive amount of urban traffic data out there compiled by both public and private sectors. But it’s been difficult to design mobility models and transportation systems based on that data because every source wants to protect its data for different purposes. On top of all that, there are privacy issues that people are rightfully concerned about.
The question then turned to regulation, which is sometimes a waypoint of implementation. For that, Guillaume Lavoie recommended not to jump straight to regulations before the subject is fully understood – that would be worse than not regulating at all. “The goal is to have the least possible, to access as much as possible,” he said.

Governance

Public Policies naturally lead to Governance. How do you build the consensus and the principles everyone has agreed on during the development of public policies into a long-term governance system? In short, as Agathe Lehel – Projects Promoter of OuiShare Québec – so succinctly put it, “How do you make sure that [governance] culture persists over time?”
Technology was consistently proposed as a possible solution. Technology can facilitate the processing of governance processes because of its dynamic ability to provide real-time information and instantaneous feedback.
One of the most promising technological applications in governance comes in the form of smart contracts in blockchain. The potential of blockchain as a governance tool is so strong that it has been adopted by businesses and even governments such as Estonia’s digital republic.
Blockchain platforms are designed to evenly distribute the power of governance and direction that decisions take. In that sense, members of the platform are simultaneously users, investors, and stakeholders. All these members are brought together from different cultures and values. The issue is how we make it work and achieve consensus.
Another concern raised in the discussion was maintaining decentralization. What we want to avoid is the consolidation of power in any extreme and not knowing who actually holds the power.
In response to the governance concerns of blockchain, Pascal Ngo Chu – co-founder of EOS/Steem Québec – pointed to EOSIO as an example. It is a blockchain platform that introduces a governance model. A constitution can be created first, which all other application systems must follow. From there, a democratic system can be established with voting tools for people to make decisions.
At the end of the day though, it’s the individuals who form the hub of a blockchain network. Yes, government needs to be involved in supporting the system, but the grassroots level needs to first demonstrate that it works even in a rapidly evolving society. However the platform is designed, governance has to be ingrained yet remain flexible enough for new directions.
We also have to remember that the platform is not the solution – it is a tool for governance and transparency that works so long as the human connection is stable.

Habitation

For all the talk about progress in society, it can’t go very far if the basic needs of the people aren’t met. That brings us to the theme of Habitation.
We’ve seen the steady rise of housing costs for years and it’s time we come up with creative solutions to combat that issue.
Many ideas were pitched at the eco2FEST workshops, including transitional use of vacant spaces. So rather than leaving undeveloped lots sitting empty, is there a way we can make use of them? The same goes for unoccupied buildings or infrastructure. What would a system that temporarily repurposes vacant spaces look like?
Housing cooperatives were also mentioned as proven working models, although everyone acknowledged that they do have some hurdles to overcome. These include setting up reliable conflict resolution systems as well as systems properly recognizing everyone’s specialties and contributions.
The most significant hurdle has to do with the public image of housing cooperatives. They are neither social housing nor places where everyone is expected to scrub the common floors together. Housing cooperatives are all about lowering the housing costs for their members. If that is what everyone ultimately wants, why is participation still so low?
It seems that housing cooperatives could do with more support from governments and more re-branding campaigns from the private sector.

Urban Agriculture and Food Sovereignty

Food is another basic need that needs to be addressed. And in an urban environment, it’s even more important that sustainable approaches are used.
It was fitting that communal food was served throughout eco2FEST, but especially so during the urban agriculture workshops. It ties in with the fact that it really does not require massive infrastructure to feed people.
What emerged from the discussions was the need for us to completely change our way of thinking when it comes to urban agriculture and food sovereignty. In a sense, we need to think big in small systems.
For instance, we can first change our concept of food consumption. Instead of consuming what we want, we can start by consuming what we want among what’s locally available. That would cut down on infrastructure being used to produce food for distant locations, along with all the transportation costs that come with it.
Douglas Jack, a sustainable community development expert, gave a presentation advocating people to take a 3D approach to agriculture. That involves considering the collaborative effect of plants occupying all height levels – from trees to fungi – that contribute to a healthier ecosystem. He also talked about various indigenous techniques for sustainable livelihood, the details of which he catalogued online for open-source sharing.
From his example as well as that of Jack SoRelle – who created the Plenty4All organization from scratch – there was a consensus that open-source sharing of agricultural techniques is an economically feasible way to establish grassroots-oriented solutions for communities all over the world.

As the second week of eco2FEST came to a close, it was apparent that there is a common thread that ran through these four themes: it all comes down to education.

It’s about learning how to let your voice be heard; it’s about teaching how to run an equitable society. It’s about learning how to live affordably together; it’s about teaching how to feed the world sustainably.

What inspired you the most from the conversations you’ve had last week at eco2FEST? What would you like to accomplish by the final week?

Winluck Wong is a freelance writer helping companies grow their businesses through blogging, web content writing, copywriting, and social media management. He gets excited about an eclectic mix of topics from business strategies and sustainable development to personal finance and life hacks. Follow his cheeky musings on Twitter and imagine how he can fit in your story on his website.