Beyond open access: making the commons economically sustainable
For decades, the open-source movement has demonstrated that people can create extraordinary things by collaborating, sharing knowledge and building upon each other's work.
Linux, Wikipedia, collaborative design, open hardware and countless other initiatives have demonstrated the productive power of the commons.
Yet an important problem remains unresolved:
How can we ensure that the economic benefits generated through the use of collectively produced resources contribute to sustaining the people and communities that create them?
Open licenses have made knowledge accessible. Copyleft licenses have helped prevent the enclosure of shared knowledge through proprietary derivatives. The Peer Production License proposed by the P2P Foundation introduces reciprocity based on the nature of the economic organization exploiting the commons.
But peer production networks are evolving. They are developing new ways to organize productive activities, coordinate contributions, distribute benefits and govern shared resources.
Their legal and economic infrastructure needs to evolve accordingly.
This is why we are developing the OVN License.
Our objective is to create a licensing framework that connects the legal conditions for using shared resources with the economic principles and organizational practices of peer-to-peer (P2P) production networks.
We want to make it possible to share openly, collaborate freely, build upon previous contributions and generate economic activity, while establishing meaningful reciprocity between those who use the commons and those who sustain it.
And we want this framework to be useful beyond any single organization or project.
The problem with existing licensing approaches
Copyright is fundamentally a legal mechanism that gives creators control over certain uses of their original works. Licenses use that legal framework to grant permissions to others.
Over time, different licensing approaches have emerged to address different concerns.
Copyright and conventional proprietary licensing
The traditional proprietary model gives rights holders considerable control over how their work can be used, modified and redistributed. Access and commercial exploitation are generally subject to permission and contractual conditions.
This model is compatible with centralized ownership and commercial appropriation, but it does not naturally support open collaboration.
Copyleft: protecting the freedom of the commons
Licenses such as the GNU General Public License (GPL) introduced a powerful alternative.
They allow people to use, modify and redistribute software, including commercially, while requiring derivative distributions to preserve the same freedoms.
Copyleft protects the commons against certain forms of enclosure: someone cannot take GPL-covered software, create a derivative version and distribute it under restrictive proprietary terms.
This is an essential achievement.
However, copyleft does not generally require commercial users to contribute financially or otherwise to the communities maintaining the software. A company can build a profitable business around GPL software without directly supporting its development, provided it respects the license's distribution obligations.
The GPL protects the freedom of the code. It does not necessarily protect the economic sustainability of its contributors.
The Peer Production License: introducing economic reciprocity
The P2P Foundation's Peer Production License (PPL) takes another step.
It distinguishes between different types of economic actors.
Non-commercial use is permitted, while commercial exploitation is restricted to worker-owned businesses and collectives that distribute their financial gains, surplus and benefits among their worker-owners.
Privately owned businesses that generate profits from the labor of salaried employees cannot commercially exploit the work under the PPL.
This is an important contribution to the development of commons-oriented economic models.
It recognizes that not all forms of commercial activity are economically or socially equivalent.
However, it also introduces a relatively specific organizational criterion: worker ownership and distribution of surplus among worker-owners.
What happens when production is organized through a network of independent contributors, cooperatives, nonprofits, small businesses, individual entrepreneurs and other complementary economic actors?
What happens when contributions are distributed across organizational boundaries, and benefits are redistributed according to participation rather than conventional ownership?
What happens when the commons is maintained by a fluid network rather than a single cooperative?
These questions motivated us to explore another approach.
The P2P paradigm requires a different economic logic
The OVN License emerges from a broader distinction between traditional economic paradigms and peer-to-peer production.
Traditional economic models tend to organize production around identifiable firms, ownership structures, employment relationships, contractual exchanges and the accumulation or distribution of profits.
These mechanisms have their place. But they are not the only possible way to organize economic activity.
In a P2P paradigm, production is organized around distributed capabilities, voluntary participation, shared resources, open collaboration and networks of relationships.
Participants can contribute different things, at different times and through different organizational arrangements.
A person can contribute software development, another can provide materials, another can coordinate activities, and another can offer infrastructure, expertise or access to users or markets.
These contributions do not necessarily take place within a single company or employment relationship.
The network becomes the productive structure.
This changes the economic questions we need to ask.
Instead of asking exclusively:
- Who owns the company?
- Who employs whom?
- Who owns the intellectual property?
- Who receives profits as an owner?
We also need to ask:
- Who contributes to the productive process?
- Who maintains and improves shared resources?
- How are contributions recognized?
- How are benefits redistributed?
- How can external economic actors use shared resources without undermining the network that sustains them?
- How can different organizations cooperate without having to merge into one legal entity?
Contribution becomes an important organizing principle alongside ownership, employment and capital.
This does not mean eliminating markets, businesses or private property. It means creating an economic environment in which these mechanisms can coexist with commons-based production and network-based coordination.
We see this as part of the transition towards a regenerative economy.
A regenerative economy does more than reduce negative externalities. It seeks to replenish the social, ecological and productive conditions on which economic activity depends.
A productive network should be able to reproduce and improve its own capacity to produce: its knowledge, infrastructure, relationships, skills, resources and collective intelligence.
A commons that generates economic benefits but cannot sustain the people and infrastructure maintaining it is not economically regenerative.
What is the OVN License trying to achieve?
The OVN License is intended to establish a legal framework for reciprocal relationships between shared resources, their contributors and the economic networks that sustain them.
Its ambition is to connect three dimensions:
1. The commons
Resources should remain accessible, reusable and improvable. The legal framework should protect their shared character and prevent inappropriate enclosure.
2. Contribution
The people and organizations contributing to the creation, maintenance and improvement of shared resources should be recognized as participants in a productive ecosystem.
3. Reciprocity
Economic actors benefiting from shared resources should participate in sustaining the commons, either through qualifying contributions, agreed economic arrangements or other forms of reciprocity.
The objective is not to impose a universal economic model on every user.
It is to provide a framework within which different P2P networks can establish their own rules for participation, reciprocity and benefit redistribution.
The license should recognize that a network's economic relationships are more complex than a simple relationship between an author and a user.
The main design choices
Developing this framework has required several important conceptual choices.
Choice 1: A generic framework, not a license restricted to Sensorica
The framework originates in the practical experience of Sensorica, an Open Value Network (OVN).
However, we do not want to create a license that only makes sense within Sensorica or depends on its specific organizational structure.
We are therefore developing a generic Commons Framework.
It uses concepts such as:
- Artifact: a resource covered by the licensing framework, such as software, documentation, designs or other productive outputs.
- Contributor: an individual or organization contributing to the creation, maintenance or improvement of an artifact.
- Affiliate: an actor associated with a P2P economic network.
- Lineage: the traceable history of an artifact and its successive contributions and transformations.
- Canonical artifact: the recognized reference version of a shared resource.
- Contribution: an activity or input that helps create, maintain or improve a resource.
- Reciprocity: the obligations or arrangements through which users contribute to sustaining the commons.
- P2P economic network: the network within which resources, contributions and economic relationships are organized.
- External-use agreement: an arrangement governing uses that require additional reciprocity or authorization.
- Resource-specific module: provisions adapted to the characteristics of a particular category of resource.
This generic foundation allows different P2P networks to adopt the framework and define their own implementation rules.
Nondominium and Sensorica's existing practices are examples of possible implementations, not prerequisites for adoption.
Choice 2: Reciprocity rather than a simple commercial/non-commercial distinction
A major limitation of many licensing approaches is their reliance on a binary distinction between commercial and non-commercial use.
Economic reality is more complex.
A cooperative can conduct commercial activities while contributing to the commons. A small business can generate revenue while participating in a productive network. A nonprofit can generate substantial economic value. An individual can use shared resources commercially without being part of a conventional company.
Conversely, an organization can use resources without directly paying for them while extracting substantial economic benefits from the collective work behind them.
We want the framework to recognize the nature of the relationship with the commons, not simply whether money changes hands.
This is why reciprocity is central to the OVN approach.
The specific reciprocity arrangements can be defined through the applicable network rules and external-use agreements.
Choice 3: Contribution rather than ownership as the basis for participation
Conventional economic arrangements often distribute benefits according to ownership, capital investment or employment status.
OVNs introduce another possibility: recognizing contributions to a productive network and using contribution-based mechanisms to redistribute benefits.
This does not mean that every contribution has to be valued in money, or that every participant receives an identical share.
Different networks can establish their own methods for recognizing contributions and distributing benefits.
The important distinction is that participation in the economic benefits of a commons need not be exclusively determined by ownership of the organization or its intellectual property.
Choice 4: Protecting the commons without preventing economic activity
We do not want to create another framework that makes it difficult to build businesses around open resources.
The objective is not to prevent commercialization.
It is to establish conditions under which economic activity can coexist with the sustainability of the commons.
This means addressing situations where organizations benefit from collectively produced resources without contributing to their maintenance, development or reproduction.
It also means making room for external users who are willing to establish appropriate reciprocal arrangements.
Choice 5: Traceability and lineage
A productive resource does not necessarily have a single creator.
It can evolve through successive contributions from different people and organizations.
The framework therefore needs to recognize the lineage of artifacts, their canonical versions and the contributions made throughout their evolution.
This is important not only for attribution, but also for recognizing the distributed nature of production and establishing legitimate relationships between contributors, resources and networks.
Choice 6: Modular design
Software, hardware, documentation, designs and other resources do not necessarily have identical legal and practical requirements.
Rather than forcing every resource into one rigid set of rules, we are developing a common framework with resource-specific modules.
The first module under development concerns software.
This module addresses the rights and conditions associated with running, using, copying, modifying, integrating, distributing, hosting and forking software, as well as the recognition of lineage, qualifying improvements and reciprocal arrangements.
The intention is to create a coherent framework that can subsequently be extended to other resource categories.
How is this different from the Peer Production License?
We see the P2P Foundation's Peer Production License as an important predecessor and source of inspiration.
Both approaches recognize that the commons should not be treated as an unlimited source of resources for extractive commercial activity.
However, their approaches to reciprocity differ.
The Peer Production License establishes a particular distinction between non-commercial use and commercial use by worker-owned businesses and collectives.
The OVN License explores a broader network-oriented framework.
Rather than making worker ownership the universal criterion for legitimate commercial exploitation, it seeks to establish relationships between the use of resources, contribution, network participation and reciprocal arrangements.
This distinction matters because a P2P network can involve many different economic actors without requiring them to adopt the same legal or ownership structure.
A cooperative, an independent contributor, a nonprofit, a small enterprise and a community organization can all participate in the same productive network.
The question becomes how their relationships with the commons are organized, not whether they all fit into one organizational category.
The OVN License is therefore not intended to replace the Peer Production License. It explores another approach to commons-based reciprocity, designed around distributed economic networks.
6. Sensorica: a practical origin for this work
This work is not emerging from abstract legal speculation.
It is rooted in years of experimentation with Sensorica, an Open Value Network.
Sensorica has explored ways to organize collaborative production without relying exclusively on conventional company structures.
Its practices include:
- Distributed participation by individuals and organizations.
- Shared productive resources and infrastructure.
- Open contribution accounting.
- Recognition of different forms of contribution.
- Network-based coordination and governance.
- Mechanisms for redistributing benefits according to participation.
- Collaboration between independent economic actors.
One important conceptual distinction in this approach is between ownership and participation rights.
A contributor does not necessarily need to own a portion of an organization or an intellectual property asset to participate in the benefits generated through their contributions.
This opens the possibility of organizing productive relationships around contribution-derived participation rather than conventional equity ownership.
The OVN License seeks to give part of this economic architecture a legal expression.
It is an attempt to connect the commons with the economic practices that sustain it.
7. Nondominium: the technological infrastructure
The development of the OVN License is also connected to Nondominium.
Nondominium is an open-source infrastructure developed within the Sensorica ecosystem, using Holochain and the Valueflows/hREA data model to represent resources, agents, economic events and productive relationships.
It is not a blockchain-based system.
Its agent-centric architecture offers possibilities for representing distributed networks without requiring all participants to depend on a single centralized platform.
This is relevant because a licensing framework based on contribution, resource lineage and network reciprocity needs more than legal text.
It needs ways to represent and validate the relationships described by that framework.
For example:
- Which resource is covered by the license?
- What is its canonical version?
- Who contributed to its creation or improvement?
- How are successive versions related?
- Which network recognizes or validates particular contributions?
- What reciprocal arrangements apply to external users?
- How are benefits associated with contributions?
Nondominium can provide technological infrastructure for representing these relationships.
The license and the software have different functions.
The license establishes legal permissions and obligations. The infrastructure provides mechanisms to record, coordinate and validate relevant information and activities.
Neither replaces the other.
Together, they can help make a network-based economic model operational.
8. How can people involved in open source benefit?
The OVN License is intended to address several persistent problems in open production.
The sustainability problem
Many open-source projects depend on unpaid labor, grants, donations or the goodwill of a relatively small group of maintainers.
The work can generate substantial economic value elsewhere, while the people maintaining it struggle to sustain their activities.
The framework explores ways to establish reciprocal relationships between users and the commons.
The free-rider and extraction problem
An organization can build a profitable business around collectively produced resources without supporting the people and infrastructure behind them.
The license seeks to provide mechanisms for addressing this asymmetry.
The organizational mismatch problem
Many open licenses assume a relatively straightforward relationship between an author, a work and its users.
But peer production is often distributed across individuals, cooperatives, nonprofits, businesses and informal groups.
The OVN framework is designed to accommodate this diversity.
The contribution-recognition problem
Conventional intellectual property arrangements tend to emphasize authorship and ownership.
They do not necessarily capture the broader network of contributions involved in maintaining and evolving a resource.
The framework introduces contribution and lineage as important dimensions.
The fragmentation problem
Different networks often develop their own rules and mechanisms for sharing resources and distributing benefits.
A common conceptual and legal framework could facilitate interoperability and cooperation between them.
The commercialization dilemma
Open-source contributors should not have to choose between making their work accessible and protecting the economic sustainability of the productive community.
We want to explore a third possibility: open sharing combined with meaningful economic reciprocity.
Not just for Sensorica: an invitation to other P2P networks
Although the framework originates in Sensorica's experience, it is not intended to be exclusive to Sensorica.
We believe it could be useful to:
- Open-source software communities.
- Open hardware initiatives.
- Worker cooperatives and open cooperativism projects.
- Commons-based peer production networks.
- Distributed research and innovation networks.
- Circular economy initiatives.
- Community-based manufacturing networks.
- Ecological and regenerative economy initiatives.
- Federated networks of independent organizations.
Different networks will have different economic models, governance arrangements and contribution-recognition mechanisms.
The framework should allow this diversity rather than impose one organizational template.
The idea is to provide a common legal foundation that networks can adapt through their own social and economic rules.
We are developing this as an open framework, and we welcome critical feedback, experimentation and collaboration.
Towards an economy that can reproduce itself
The deeper motivation behind this work is a transition in how we understand production and economic organization.
The industrial economy has largely organized production around capital accumulation, hierarchical firms, ownership and market transactions.
Open-source and commons-based production have demonstrated that another form of productive organization is possible.
But openness alone is not enough.
A commons needs people who maintain it, infrastructure that supports it, resources that enable it to grow and economic mechanisms that allow its contributors to sustain their activities.
We need to move beyond the idea that sharing and economic sustainability are opposing objectives.
We need mechanisms that allow them to reinforce each other.
The P2P paradigm offers a different way of organizing productive capacity: through distributed networks, shared resources, contribution, collaboration and adaptive governance.
The regenerative economy adds another important dimension: economic activity should reproduce and strengthen the social, ecological and productive conditions on which it depends.
The OVN License is one contribution towards that transition.
It is an attempt to develop legal infrastructure for a world in which the commons can remain open, productive networks can sustain themselves, and economic benefits can circulate in ways that reinforce rather than undermine collective productive capacity.
Our ambition is simple, but consequential:
Make it possible to build an economy around shared resources without making the people who create and sustain those resources economically invisible.
Make reciprocity part of the architecture of the commons.
And make the legal infrastructure of peer production evolve alongside its technological and organizational infrastructure.
The commons should not merely be open. It should be sustainable, productive and regenerative.












